| # | Song | V. Solo | Notes | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Carol of the Bells | No choir | ||
| 2 | Little Town | |||
| 3 | Angels from the Realms | |||
| 4 | Gloria Vivaldi | |||
| 5 | For Onto Us | 1 | Lauren | |
| 6 | Be Born in Me | 1 | April | |
| 7 | He Shall Purify | 1 | Pennie | |
| 8 | Silver Bells | |||
| 9 | Christmas Angels | 3 | Kids | |
| 10 | Star of Wonder | No choir | ||
| 11 | Children Go | 2 | Solo: Erin, Rap: Edmerald | |
| 12 | A la Nanita Nana | |||
| 13 | Still, Stil | 1 | Julie | |
| 14 | Oughta Know | 1 | Brittany | |
| 15 | Good Weather | 1 | Arden | |
| 16 | Hallelujah, Light Has Come | 3 | Tricia; Robin, Gracie | |
| 17 | Ancient Nova | |||
| 18 | Go Tell It | 2 | Elizabeth, Edmerald | |
| 19 | Have Yourself | |||
| 20 | Joy, Joy | 1 | Noshi | |
| E1 | The Great Day | 2 | Olivia, Zeke | |
| E2 | Before the King | 1 | Elizabeth | |